One of the first things anyone with a pulse noticed the day after the Golden Isles by-election was that voter turnout was low. Naturally, the New Day Progressive Liberal Party (PLP) treated this like a personal insult to their “great” victory and promptly launched into an Olympic-level gymnastics routine to explain why only around half of registered voters bothered to show up.
And then came their proclamation:
“Here are the facts.”
Whenever the PLP starts a sentence like that, you really should tighten your seatbelt, grab the dashboard, and hope your insurance covers political whiplash. Because I’ve long realized there are facts, and then there are PLP facts—and the two have never been caught in the same room.
According to the PLP’s freshly baked narrative, the voter register—established in 2016—shouldn’t be trusted because apparently thousands of Golden Isles voters have scattered like witnesses leaving a crime scene over the past nine years. Never mind that the Parliamentary Commissioner exists precisely to maintain that register.

The PLP insists that, thanks to their five-week door-to-door safari, they discovered the real number of eligible voters is somewhere between 5,200 and 5,500. Voilà! With their newly invented denominator, suddenly turnout wasn’t a bleak 49 percent—it was a heroic 70 percent! And with that, the PLP proudly declared that their supporters “answered the call.”
Beautiful story. Almost touching. Except for one tiny detail:
It directly contradicts the Parliamentary Commissioner himself.

Harrison Thompson—the man legally responsible for the voter register—did not mince words. He was, in his own phrasing, “baffled” by the low turnout. Not reassured. Not impressed. Not spinning gold from straw. Baffled.
From The Nassau Guardian:
Of the 7,926 registered voters in Golden Isles, only 3,884 showed up.
Turnout: 49 percent.
Not 70.
Not 80.
Not whatever number the PLP cooked up in their backroom kitchen.
Thompson even emphasized:
The 7,926 people do live in Golden Isles.
The register is cleaned daily.
Over 16,000 names have been removed since 2017.
They expected more voters because all attention was on a single constituency.
So, unless we assume the Parliamentary Commissioner is incompetent (which the PLP would never say out loud—though their “facts” strongly imply it), then the PLP’s alternative reality looks suspiciously like political creative writing.
But the New Day PLP—true to form—expects Bahamians to ignore the Parliamentary Commissioner, ignore the numbers, ignore the laws governing elections, and simply trust them. Because nothing says “New Day” quite like telling the public, “Don’t believe the official responsible for elections; believe us—we canvassed for five weeks.”
I’m not saying the PLP doesn’t understand something. I’m just asking: are they seriously telling us that the man who manages the register, cleans it daily, and oversees the voting process… is wrong?
The Bahamas deserves better.


